Home Home Initiatives Comments Insight Publications Correspondence Search Resources Profiles Upcoming


 

If This is a Free Society Why Are We Hounding Juliet O'Neill
Lawrence Martin
Jihadists Don't Care About Logic
George Jonas
How to Win a War: The Ethiopian Example
Jack Kelly
Ontario's Whiff of Totalitarianism
Robert Fulford
A Determined Harper Flexes His Foreign Affairs Muscles
Barbara Yaffe
What next? Anti-harassment training in the crib?
Ian A. Hunter
Be Careful What You Wish For
John O'Sullivan
Israel Will Do Whatever It Takes
Douglas Davis
Leadership at Last
John C. Crosbie
Human Rights Carry a Price for Canada
Lorne Gunter
Don't Share a Table With the Taliban
Lauryn Oates
Dealing Decisively With the enemy
Frank Gaffney,Jr.
War? What war?
Andrew C. McCarthy
What the Crime Stats Don't Tell You
Dan Gardner
Canada and Kandahar
Beryl P. Wajsman
The Stuff of Leadership
Beryl P. Wajsman
The Secret Mulroney Tapes: A Quick Job for a Quick Buck
John C. Crosbie
A Victory for Multiculturalism over Common Sense
Mark Steyn
Bravo M. Bush!
Jacques Brassard
Europe-Thy Name is Cowardice
Mathias Daepfner
The Price of Justice
Me. Julius Grey
Don't Let Deals Devour Democracy
Thomas S. Axworthy
A Country Going To Pieces
Michael Bliss
Robbery, Québec Style
Prof.Pierre Lemieux
"It's about Barbarism and Civilization"
The Brigitte Gabriel Lecture at Duke University

Le Coran plutôt que la Charte des droits?
Élaine Audet
"Unions = Justice"
Janet Bagnall
The Delusions and Denials of the Left: A Study in Contradiction and Incoherence
Janet Daley
Radical Relativism and the War in Iraq
Elizabeth Nickson
Crise Irakienne: Ces Pacifistes Contre la Paix
Prof.Jean-Charles Chebat
Chaire de commerce Omer DeSerres- HEC Montréal
Vice-président de l'Académie des Sciences du Canada
Sen.Daniel Patrick Moynihan: A Mind of One Piece, A Man for our Time
Beryl P. Wajsmann
UN Lets Tinpot Dictators Rule The World
Janet Daley
Signature of a Society:Jack,Paul,Sheila and the Wajsman Manifesto
Jim Duff
Le fascisme de gauche à l'UQAM et ailleurs
Prof.Stephen Schecter
"The legislature can't reform it, the lawmakers won't repeal it and I won't stand for it.":The Commutation of Death Penalties In Illinois-The Complete Text
Gov.George H. Ryan
The Death Penalty:A Continuing Blight on the Rights of Man
Washington Post Editorial
Bishops Can't Bring Peace on Earth:Religious Leaders Have No Monopoly On Good
Mary Riddell
La nouvelle panoplie du terrorisme:Une analyse
Jacques Isnard
Orwellian Prophecy and Our Time:The Compromise of Human Spirit and the Enforcement of Conformity
Prof.Julius Grey
War is the Only Option:We Must Stop Saddam's Killing Machine
Elie Wiesel
La présomption d'innocence:La police et les conférences de presse
Yves Boisvert
A Who's Who at Institute Conference
Linda Massarella
A Citizens Agenda of Better Banks--Not a Corporate Agenda of Bigger Banks
Canadian Community Reinvestment Coalition
The Crime of Punishment: Why the Innocent Confess
Michael Kinsley
Outrepassons les partis politiques:Besoin collectif d'un but
Jean David
A Brutal Loss of Innocence: The Trauma of Terror
Andrew Mills
Un nationalisme déplorable:Le rapport Romanow--le champ de bataille
Me.Julius Grey

 


 

Labour
AFL-CIO
Canadian Committee on Labour History
Canadian Labour Congress
Canadian Social Progress
European Trade Union Institute
Fédération des travailleurs et travailleuses du Québec
Histadrut
International Confederation of Free Trade Unions
International Institute of Social History
International Labour Organization
Le Fonds de solidarité FTQ
National Committee for Labor Israel
Trade Union Advisory Committee to the OECD
Walter P. Ruether Library

Justice
Access to Justice Network
American Civil Liberties Union
Amnesty International
Association in Defence of the Wrongfully Convicted
Canadian Banking Ombudsman
Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms
Canadian Civil Liberties Association
Canadian Coalition Against the Death Penalty
Canadian Human Rights Commission
Canadian Taxpayers Federation
Center for Wrongful Convictions:Northwestern Law School
Charte des droits et libertés de la personne du Québec
Freedom From Want:The Four Freedoms Program
Freedom of Information Coalition
Human Rights Appeal of the Liberal International:The Ottawa Declaration 1987
Human Rights Watch
International Covenant on Civil & Political Rights
International Covenant on Ecomomic, Social & Cultural Rights
John Howard Society of Canada
L'aide juridique du Québec
Le Protecteur du Citoyen
Legal Aid:Access to Justice
Privacy Commissioner of Canada
Southern Poverty Law Center
Universal Declaration of Human Rights

Economic & Social Policy

Foreign & Military Affairs

Think Tanks


Organized Labour and Charest's Third Way

The Danger of the Gaspesia Gambit

Beryl P. Wajsman & James C. Duff

10 November 2004


“Villainous company hath been the spoil of me.”

~ Shakespeare, “Falstaff”

 

 

One might be forgiven for wondering what happened to the wave of populist anger that was supposed to have taken to our streets this fall in protest against the Charest government’s plans to re-engineer the Quebec economic model. Was there a new status quo in place?


Apart from a modest four-day walkout this past weekend by 3,800 SAQ employees and a union blitz at the Jonquiere Wal-Mart, this has been one of the calmest falls in the recent history of Liberal governance, an accomplishment little short of astounding in a political jurisdiction where some 40 percent of the population has a tie to organized labour, a level approached only in Denmark, Sweden, Italy and Israel.

 

The big reason was the decision by the Quebec Federation of Labour (FTQ) to sit out a proposed one-day general strike that the hospital and public-service unions had hoped would send the message to the Charest Liberals that privatization wouldn’t fly. The Liberals’ intimacies that led to the FTQ’s decision are now crumbling under perceived Liberal betrayals in the Gaspesia blame game. If the government goes too far in union-bashing, last year’s demonstrations could be dwarfed by things to come.

 

Upon his election Jean Charest vowed to remake what he called the “Quebec model”. Ostensibly what he had in mind was to reduce government intervention in, and cut state engineering of, the economic and financial directions and decisions in this Province. His version of English Prime Minister Tony Blair’s ‘Third Way’. But hidden landmines that threatened structural failure were never cleared.

 

It was a fully legitimate political position of course. After all, reducing state involvement is the backbone of conservative thought. However, it succeeds only within a thoroughly thought out policy framework. Without one, a new broom sweeping out a generation of  entrenched constructs produces dire consequences. Unfortunately the Liberal government had no defining moment comparable to Margaret Thatcher slamming down a copy of Friedrich Hayek’s ‘The Constitution of Liberty’ and barking at the British press “This is what we believe!”

 

Clearly there were problems with the Caisse-SGF-Investissements Québec world. But despite them Quebec’s economic engine helped propel Montreal ahead of Toronto in total investment dollars for the first time in a generation in the last two years of the PQ mandate. Precisely because partnerships with state institutions were possible, we attracted major engagement from foreign investors. And some of the successes were quite dramatic. A case in point being the $100 million plus joint venture between SGF Santé and the Netherlands’ DSM-Biologic, the world’s second largest generic pill maker, that resulted in the construction of Canada’s first laboratory for the testing of new pharmaceuticals on humans and the creation of several hundred jobs.

 

As the dismantling of  ‘Québec Inc.’ began to attract negative attention to its directionless nature, the government turned its attention from the economic to the social side of the agenda. And everything that was touched created bitter discord and division. Clawbacks on  pharmacy drug costs for the elderly. Tightening of immigration rules that some critics called racial profiling. A proposed elimination of local community representation on health-care boards. Six months into its mandate the new government was reeling with the lowest approval numbers in history. Then came the attack on Section 45 of the Labour Code.

 

The Charest government sought to allow a greater degree of outsourcing in the public and private sectors. A key element of its neo-lib-con ‘Third Way’. This required a change to an essential part of the status quo on labour relations. As much as Quebec’s unions were troubled by the socio-economic policies of this government their concerns had been voiced in the media and in consultative sessions with Mr. Charest and his Minister of Labour. Until now.

 

The leaders of organized labour appealed to Mr. Charest in face-to-face meetings not to go through with a one-sided reform. Henri Massé, President of the FTQ, strongly urged the government to seek a compromise by working in a step-by-step approach with labour. But it was clear that as last year’s Indian summer turned into fall, resolution was far away. It was then that Quebec’s major unions began to plan for the largest common front demonstrations in a generation.

 

This was not done without some trepidation. Many union leaders felt Quebec workers would take to the streets only on money issues. There was concern that Quebecers could not grasp the implications of such a broad opposition to a majority government’s entire approach. Or why it was so important at this time. Finally, they were fearful that if their call for mobilization failed, their own legitimacy would be put into question.

 

Their fears were ill-founded. The people grasped the issues viscerally. In a society of much bounty but with only a thin veneer of affluence where over 20% of the able-bodied cannot find work and where one-third of the gainfully employed are ‘working poor’ with only a few weeks of salary to their names, the people rose as one and one million took to the streets on December 11th of last year. The Gazette headline said it all: “Round 1 To The Unions”.

 

But as a one-day Round 2 general strike for earlier this year was being planned, the air was slowly seeping out of the balloon. In Joseph Heller’s immortal words “Something Happened”. Even as a record 150,000 people were turning out for the May Day March led by Henri Massé, the momentum was changing.

 

The Charest government was fast realizing that its economic policies could create dislocations of grave proportions. As the book value of the 300 plus companies in the “Quebec Inc.” portfolios were being written down to prepare them for sale, buyers were almost non-existent. Only some 40 companies had found suitors. Without government participation, potential acquisitors began to get cold feet. Syndicates formed with major American capital partners were evaporating as it became clear that there would no state supports or subventions. Thousand of jobs would be lost.

 

The Liberal government began to make some profound changes. The reality sunk in that in order to attract foreign investors some partnership with Quebec institutions had to be created. The only place where disposable funds that large resided were with the unions. Overtures began from the highest government mandarins to the leaders of organized labour. Work with us. Look at these investment syndicates. Try and take a lead. Help us and…you guessed it…we won’t push Sec.45 reform.

 

This process continued through the summer and early fall. Even as some of the ablest labor leaders such as Louis Bolduc of the United Food and Commercial Workers were organizing Wal-Mart, a consensus was building that there was much to be gained by prudence. Co-operation not confrontation was the by-word. Then came the Health-Care Summit.

 

Historically, disagreements between labour and government in Quebec take a back seat to a united voice in power-sharing negotiations with Ottawa. Charest’s approach of asymmetrical federalism fit right in with the mind-set of labour’s leadership. Labour felt an organizational, and ideological, imperative to support a new common front that could reverse twenty years of Trudeau-inspired federal strength. Here was an opening to out-Meech-Meech. And it succeeded.

 

Political expediency dictated that Martin and Charest needed perceived victories. And they got just that. Perceived wins. Nothing would make the capitulation at the Ottawa Congress Centre right. The people would not helped. Suffering would not be reduced. But the provinces got more power. Charest and labours’ leaders could declare they championed Quebec’s broader interests. The tentative truce between the Liberals and labour held.

 

But as the blame game unfolds in the Gaspesia debacle, all further bets on labour peace are off. Last Friday, Radio-Canada was leaked an internal auditor’s report into the cost overruns at the former Abitibi Consolidated paper plant in Chandler, showing that the former Péquiste government was in such a rush to get the paper plant running again for purely political reasons, it squandered $78 million on mid-construction changes.

 

Meanwhile, the carefully chosen commissioners of the government’s inquiry have been making noises that this occurred in order to solidify a pre-election compact between the PQ and labour. Unions are viewing the government’s spin doctors as orchestrating a direct provocation to achieve a hidden agenda since the Liberals know full well that the FTQ refused to endorse Landry’s PQ in the last election.


The Charest government appears to be seizing on the Gaspesia saga in the hope that it will convince Quebeckers beyond a reasonable doubt that the Quebec model of state capitalism is irreparably broken, with public-private partnerships being the only way to go. But the difference this time is that Big Labour has a $70 million stake in the idle, partially renovated Gaspesia mill.

 

The FTQ was a partner in this ill-fated venture with the Societe generale du financement and papermaker Tembec and if liquidator Ernst and Young is successful in convincing a judge this week to allow it to sell off the mill in pieces, the FTQ’s Fonds de solidarité stands to lose every cent and the paperworkers of Chandler will lose any chance of seeing the mill in operation ever again.


The Charest Liberals may have gone too far in attempting to embarrass labour in order to press its case. FTQ leaders and senior advisors are holding emergency meetings to plan strategy leading up to the resumption of the Commission of Inquiry on November 30. If the FTQ breaks its silence the perceived status quo will be a distant memory.


It is to be hoped that the institutional intimacies of the past year are not turned to institutional betrayals and that Quebec labour’s proud record of progress of the past fifty years will not fall victim to Shakespeare’s Falstaffian warning that “Villainous company hath been the spoil of me.”

 

-30-

 



Email Article Format for Printing
Home Initiatives Comments Insight Publications Profiles Resources Search Correspondence


Le rapport Payette

Un autre affront à la liberté d'expression

Payette

Quebec report would submit journalists to state controls

Theodore Bikel

The soundtrack of our lives

MONTRÉAL

Freer,fairer,richer
Plus libre, plus juste,
plus riche

The Métropolitain

First Anniversary
Premier anniversaire

The Israel Apartheid Lies

A response to hate

Stimulate This!

Some permanent solutions to
a continuing crisis

RFK

"A tiny ripple of hope..."

Eternal Vigilance

Un appel aux citoyens engagés

Masada shall not fall again!

The legacy of the brave and the bold

To Rouse The World From Fear

The Legacy of JFK

Lewis MacKenzie, OC
The People's General

Going Big! Going Bold! Getting it Done!

Ardent Advocacy
The Pursuit of the Politics of Purpose

Pragmatic Radicalism and the Struggle for a
Civil Society

The Compulsion of Nonconformist Conscience

To Revive Militant Liberalism and Renew a Culture of Compassion

"Victory In Spite of All Terror"

A Policy to Vanquish
the Venom

WIESENTHAL

"And the Sun Stood Still at Mid-Day"

Twelve Days That Should Rend Our Souls Asunder

The Fierce Urgency of Now

John Paul II

A Ministry of Compassion for the
Victims of Contempt

Blind Justice in the Shadow of Life

The Tragedy of
Terri Schiavo

Mandatory Minimums

Rigorous Law
Rigorous Injustice

The Jaywalker, The Smoker and the Motherless Child

Our Bulls of Pamplona Run Amok

What we're for

Reflections on accomodation

Kafka, Kanada and Khodorkovsky

The Ghosts of
Dorian Gray

The David Irving Prosecution

The Perils of Divisible Freedoms

Harper's Triumph at the Summit

Principle Trumps Pandering

Scorn a Deluded People

Multiculturalism,Political Correctness,Moral Equivalency and the Coming Collapse of this Northern Dominion

The Shapiro Affair

A Commissioner Worthy of Contempt or a Culture Beneath Contempt?

Why Harper Won

A Victory of Character over Connivance

Liberal Renewal: A Time to Propose Not Merely Oppose

Toward a Return to Radical Liberalism

Decision Canada

A Flock of Sheep or a Pride of Lions

Canada's Nixon

Paul Martin and the Death of Canadian Liberalism

Subversion of Consequence, Perversion of Justice

Mulroney,Chretien,Martin and the Theft of a Country

Ottawa's Illiberal Agenda

The Compromise of Individual Imperative

A Legacy of Stone

The Martin-Stronach Deal

State Rape

The Scandal of Public Intrusions into
Private Lives

Extreme Prejudice: State Rape and the Death of Due Process

Our Retreat From Reason

Without Restraint of Consequence

The Rev. Darryl Gray and Our Culture of Complicity

Vertu et prohibition
Virtue and Vice

De confiner la vertu de liens raisonnables
The Self-Abnegation of the New Prohibitionists

Fatal Delusions

Culture,Immigration and the Compromise of Canadian Consequence

Exclusiveness and Intolerance

Religious Sacraments and Secular Rights

State and Faith

To Guard Against the Low Limitation of Narrow Narcissims

The Kirpan Decision

The Supremes Fail Again

The Tsunami Absolution

Empathy To Human Fate,
Apathy Toward
Human Hate

To Move A Nation

A Reflection on Leadership

Promises to Keep

The Unbearable Lightness of our
National Political Elites

A Nation Defined

Perspectives On
The Charter

A More Perfect Dominion

Time for the Canadian Republic

On Civil Conservatism

The Restraint of Reason Over Illiberal License

Neither Indulgence of Excuse Nor Excess of License

The Urgency for an Engaged Citizenry

Saudi Chutzpah and Jihadi Jigs

No Threat to the Real "Lords of War"

UN Watch

A Lesson in Law for Louise

The United Nations

30 Years of
"Brutal Buffoonery"

Lebanon Shares Hezbollah's Guilt

Lebanese Officials are Complicit

The Temper of
Our Time

A World Turned
Upside Down

Wake Up Calls From A Dangerous Time Zone

The Inherent Appeasement of
Moral Equivalency

Terms of Engagement

To Be Unreasonable
But Right

Québec & Israel

Contre la doctrine du mépris

Canada's Shame

The Victory of Shrivelled Spirit and Hostile Heart

Canada's Shame II

The Jamal Akkal Affair and our Foreign Policy Hypocrisy

Assadourian
& Al-Sudais

A Conflict of
Canadian Interests

Canada's Foreign Policy Review

A Chance at
Redemptive Change

The Institute for Public Affairs of Montreal

A Pledge of Principles

"...And Justice For All...": The Case for Fiscal Equity and Equality

An End to "Them That Has, Keeps"

Corporate Governance and Accountability:

Combinations of Institutional Intimacies and Concentrations of Unnatural Profits

Globalization and the Rights of Man

Labor's New
Crown of Thorns

“Evidence of Innocence is Irrelevant": The Death Penalty and the Illinois Experiment

The Fallibility of
Human Judgment

The Criminal Justice System: The Crimes of Punishment

The Crying Need for Legal, Penal and Parole Reform

The Quebec Election

A Transition Not a Transformation

A Matter of Prejudice

Quebec Shouldn't Accomodate
Quebec Should Acculturate

The Second Fall of Quebec Inc.

Time for an Untranquil Revolution

To Withstand Comparisons

The Challenge to Boisclair's Sovereigntists

The Colavecchio Affair

Our Ongoing Ordeal
With Civility

Quebec's Call for Clarity

What the Federal Election Results from Quebec Mean for Canada

Time to Fight
Fire with Fire

An End to the Blackmail

Hamas

The Holocaust Day Election

An Orgy of Hate: The Disgrace of Prejudice

An Open Letter to the Ministers of Justice and Immigration of Canada

To Revive Our
Courage to Loathe

An End to the Paralysis
of the Rational

A View from Amman

Or How Not to
Read the Signs

Brit Academics
Boycott Israel

Brit Proctologists
Throw Party

Re-Grinding
Avnery's Axe

The Truth of Today's Middle East Realities

The Hariri Assassination

The United Nations Condemns Syria

The Hijacking of Legacy

Irrational Theocracy, Irresponsible Theology

After Arafat: Perils and Prospects in the
Middle East

The Strategic Realities of Asymmetrical Polarization

Les masques tombent

Les enlèvements des deux journalistes français

Islamic Iconography: One Faith, One State

The Inevitable Confrontation
with the West

Les lendemains de la guerre

Vers une démocratie ou un morcellement de l’Irak ?

American Democrat Not American Caesar

The Bush Doctrine as
Pax Liberta

The American Election

Why It's About the War Stupid!

Imperatives of Assault:Legitimacy as Precursor to Sovreignty

The Case for the Bush Doctrine on Iraq

Islam Absolu

Les Débordements du Fondamentalisme Islamique

Iraq and Weapons of Mass Destruction:National Security Archive Report

American and British intelligence reports on the existence and intended use by Iraq of its WMD program.

Mid-East Backgrounder:Breaking News

U.S.,Israeli,Turkish Agreements on Iraqi Crisis

The Acquisition of Weapons of Mass Destruction:

An Unclassified CIA Report

Operation Defensive Shield-The Legality of Armed Response

The Case for Israel in International Law

Un Ami d'Israël

Dix Declarations d'Amitiés

The Politics of a Guaranteed Income:

The Tragedy of Unfulfilled Promise

Health Care: The Test of our National Consensus

The Untouchable Universal

The Passion

The Eternal Vessel for the Teaching of Contempt

They Poisoned The Wells:The Old/New Anti-Semitism

Exclusiveness and Intolerance in the Post-9/11 World

The Hype of the Hypocrites:

The Reality of the
Political Man

Ten Days That Sear Our Souls

Wallenberg, King and Auschwitz

8 May 1945

A Personal Reflection on Memory and Witness

The Man Who Would Not Be Silenced

The Unapologetic Activism of Peter Bergson

Laurier-Dorion

Everybody Take A Valium

Election 2004: The Real Polls On The Ground

34 Key Ridings

2003 Québec Election Special:

Twenty-Two Ridings to Watch

Forge of Fire:Words That Changed The World

Reflections of Transcendant Yearning for Redemptive Change:A Multimedia Presentation

Justice Shalt Thou Pursue

The Institute's Response to a Time of Challenge

 


 

Archives-The Agenda
Front Page
RFK & PET: Our Beginnings in Advocacy
A Photo Gallery
A Statement of Purpose
Why We Do What We Do
Beryl P. Wajsman, Esq.
Founder and President
Jack Cola
Chairman of Council
Jack Dym
Vice-Chairman of Council
INSTITUTE SCHOLARS
David H. Romano, Ph.D.
Albert A. Zbily, M.A.
A Profile of the Founder and President:
Beryl P. Wajsman,Esq.
ADVISORY COUNCIL
John F. Angus
Corporate Governance and Banking Accountability
Prof. Julius Grey
Constitutional & Charter Rights and Law Reform
Me.Richard J. McConomy
Judicial Affairs and Legislative Initiatives
Prof.Annette Paquot
International Affairs
Maj.-Gen. (ret.) Lewis W. MacKenzie
National Defence and International Military Affairs
Terence J. Corcoran
Public Security
David B. Harris
Domestic and International Intelligence
Patrick Gagnon
National Political Affairs
Ruth Kovac
Municipal Affairs
Dr.André Dascal
National Health Policy
Hal Newman
Health Care and Social Services
Toni Cochand
Poverty and Homelessness
Nino Colavecchio
Multiculturalism
Rev.Darryl G. Gray
Empowerment
Rabbi Yonah Rosner
Inter-Community Religious Affairs
Sharon Freedman,BSW
Patients' Rights and Seniors
Michel A. Bourque
Technology,Development and Privacy
CONSULTATIVE ROUNDTABLE
Francis Bellido,Ph.D.
Prof.Jean-Charles Chebat
Charles S. Coffey
James C. Duff
Louis Lacroix
Richard H. Gimblett, CD, Ph.D.
Cmdr.Charles Rabbat
Shoel Silver
Jonathan I. Wener
Members of the Roundtable are available to meet and advise on specific issues relevant to Institute initiatives and policy.
INTERNATIONAL ASSOCIATES
Robert G. Hest
(New York)
Peter Dimitroff
(Washington, D.C.)
Col. (ret.) Peter W. Reynolds
(London)
Lawrence J. Behar, Esq. (Miami)
Leonard Dykler, MBA
(Paris)
Me.Isabelle Jablonski
(Paris)
Noga Tarnopolsky
(Jerusalem)
David Harel
(Tel Aviv)
 
The articles,studies and publications on this site are not necessarily reflective of the views of all members of the Council, the Roundtable or of our international Associates.

 


Write to us